Buying vs Renting Mobile Phones

Understanding the financial implications of different smartphone purchasing options in New Zealand

When getting a new smartphone in New Zealand, you have several payment options. Understanding the true costs and benefits of each approach will help you make the best financial decision for your situation.

Buying Outright

✅ Advantages

  • Own the phone immediately
  • No monthly device payments
  • Freedom to switch plans anytime
  • Can sell or trade the phone
  • Often cheaper in the long run
  • No credit checks required

❌ Disadvantages

  • Large upfront cost ($500-$2000+)
  • No warranty beyond manufacturer
  • Responsible for insurance
  • Technology becomes outdated
  • Need to research and buy separately

Monthly Payment Plans

✅ Advantages

  • Lower upfront costs
  • Bundled with mobile plan
  • Often includes insurance
  • Upgrade options available
  • Predictable monthly payments
  • Sometimes includes extended warranty

❌ Disadvantages

  • Usually more expensive overall
  • Locked into contract terms
  • Don't own phone until paid off
  • Early termination fees
  • Credit checks required
  • Limited plan flexibility

Cost Comparison Example

iPhone 15 (128GB) - 24 Month Comparison

Option Upfront Cost Monthly Cost Total Cost (24 months) Ownership
Buy Outright + Plan $1,399 $39 (plan only) $2,335 Immediate
24-Month Contract $0-$200 $89 (phone + plan) $2,336 After 24 months
12-Month Contract $200-$400 $109 (phone + plan) $2,816 After 12 months

Which Option is Right for You?

Choose Buying Outright If:

  • You have the upfront cash available
  • You want maximum flexibility
  • You keep phones for 3+ years
  • You want to minimize total cost
  • You prefer no long-term commitments

Choose Monthly Payments If:

  • You prefer lower upfront costs
  • You want bundled insurance/warranty
  • You like upgrading every 1-2 years
  • You want predictable monthly budgeting
  • You value convenience of one bill

Tips for Each Option

If Buying Outright:

  • Shop around for the best phone prices
  • Consider previous generation models for savings
  • Look for sales during Black Friday or end of financial year
  • Choose a flexible mobile plan you can change anytime
  • Consider phone insurance separately if needed
  • Keep the phone in good condition for resale value

If Choosing Monthly Payments:

  • Read the contract terms carefully
  • Calculate the total cost over the contract period
  • Understand early termination fees
  • Check what happens if you want to upgrade early
  • Ensure the plan meets your data and calling needs
  • Consider the network coverage in your area

Alternative Options

Refurbished Phones

Buy certified refurbished phones for significant savings while still getting warranty coverage. Great middle ground between new and used.

Trade-In Programs

Many retailers offer trade-in programs where you can get credit for your old phone towards a new purchase, reducing the upfront cost.

Interest-Free Payment Plans

Some retailers offer interest-free payment plans (like Afterpay or Zip) that let you spread the cost without paying extra.

Need Help Choosing?

Our experts can help you calculate the best option based on your specific needs and budget.

Get Expert Advice